Professional vs OTC Teeth Whitening: Which is Best?

A bright, white smile can boost your confidence and make a lasting impression. If you’re considering teeth whitening, you’ve probably noticed the abundance of options available, from professional treatments to over-the-counter products. At Infinity Dental Arts in Indian Trail, NC, we believe in empowering our patients with knowledge to make informed decisions about their dental care. Let’s dive into the world of teeth whitening and compare professional services with store-bought alternatives.

Understanding Teeth Discoloration

Before we explore whitening options, it’s important to understand why teeth become discolored:

  1. Extrinsic stains: Caused by coffee, tea, red wine, tobacco, and certain foods
  2. Intrinsic stains: Result from aging, medication use, or childhood exposure to certain antibiotics
  3. Wear and tear: Thinning enamel revealing the yellower dentin underneath

Dr. Ian Alvey notes, “Understanding the cause of your tooth discoloration helps determine the most effective whitening approach.”

Professional Teeth Whitening at Infinity Dental Arts

In-Office Whitening

Process:

  • Protective gel applied to gums
  • High-concentration whitening agent applied to teeth
  • Special light or laser may be used to activate the whitening agent
  • Treatment typically lasts 60-90 minutes

Pros:

  • Fastest results (often 3-8 shades lighter in one visit)
  • Professionally supervised for safety
  • Even, consistent results

Cons:

  • More expensive than at-home options
  • May cause temporary tooth sensitivity

Dr. Dylan Sobin explains, “In-office whitening is ideal for patients seeking dramatic, immediate results or those with upcoming special events.”

Take-Home Professional Whitening Kits

Process:

  • Custom-fitted trays created from impressions of your teeth
  • Professional-grade whitening gel provided
  • Trays worn for specified periods (often 30 minutes to overnight) for 1-2 weeks

Pros:

  • Convenient for at-home use
  • Professional-strength products
  • Custom-fitted trays for even application and reduced gum irritation
  • Gradual whitening allows for control over shade

Cons:

  • Results take longer than in-office treatments
  • Requires consistent use for best results

“Take-home kits offer a great balance of professional quality and convenience,” says Dr. Alvey.

Over-the-Counter Whitening Options

Whitening Strips

Process: Flexible strips coated with a low-concentration peroxide gel, applied to teeth for specified time

Pros:

  • Widely available and affordable
  • Easy to use

Cons:

  • Lower concentration of whitening agents
  • May not fit well, leading to uneven results
  • Can cause gum irritation if not applied correctly

Whitening Toothpastes

Process: Contain mild abrasives and low concentrations of peroxide

Pros:

  • Easy to incorporate into daily routine
  • May help maintain results after other whitening treatments

Cons:

  • Minimal whitening effect
  • May be too abrasive for regular long-term use

Over-the-Counter Trays

Process: Similar to professional take-home kits but with one-size-fits-all trays

Pros:

  • More affordable than professional options
  • Can be used at home

Cons:

  • Ill-fitting trays can lead to uneven results and gum irritation
  • Lower concentration of whitening agent than professional products

Dr. Sobin cautions, “While over-the-counter products can be effective for mild staining, they often lack the power and precision of professional treatments.”

Comparing Effectiveness and Safety

Effectiveness

Professional treatments generally provide more dramatic and faster results due to:

  • Higher concentration of whitening agents
  • Custom-fitted trays or professional application
  • Combination of whitening gels and activating lights (for in-office treatments)

Over-the-counter products can be effective for maintaining whiteness or addressing mild staining but typically require longer use for noticeable results.

Safety

Professional whitening is generally safer because:

  • Treatment is supervised by dental professionals
  • Products are tailored to your specific needs
  • Precautions are taken to protect gums and sensitive areas

While over-the-counter products are generally safe when used as directed, there’s a higher risk of misuse, leading to gum irritation or uneven results.

Cost Comparison

  • In-office professional whitening: Most expensive option, but provides fastest results
  • Take-home professional kits: Moderate cost, balancing professional quality w
Scroll to Top

Book Appointment